WHEN POLITICS BEGINS TO SPEAK THE LANGUAGE OF FEAR
By Dr. Mohammed Mohammed Haruna
There is something unsettling about the language beginning to creep into Nigeria's politics as 2027 draws closer. It is not yet the election season in its fullest fury, but we are already hearing words that should make democrats uncomfortable. They are words about people leaving communities if they do not support the ruling party, about fingers being broken, opponents being shown what a “real threat” looks like, government supporters enjoying the “honey”, and even marriages being sacrificed on the altar of partisan loyalty. Perhaps some of these statements were jokes. Perhaps some were metaphors. Perhaps others were badly expressed attempts at political mobilisation. Several of those involved have indeed offered explanations, clarifications or apologies. But when similar expressions begin appearing from different political actors in different parts of the country, prudence demands that we stop laughing long enough to ask what kind of political culture we are nurturing.
In Kuje Area Council of the Federal Capital Territory, Chairman Danjuma Shekwolo was captured in a video saying that it was either people were “doing APC” or they should leave the area council. He later explained that he had been addressing party loyalists, that his comments were taken out of context and that he neither possessed the authority nor intended to disenfranchise anybody. Fair enough. Clarifications matter. Yet the troubling question remains: how did support for a political party and the right to belong in a Nigerian community find themselves in the same sentence? Kuje belongs to Nigerians, not to the APC, just as an opposition-controlled council elsewhere belongs neither to the PDP nor the Labour Party. Political parties govern places; they do not own them.
Osun brought its own controversy when Senator Francis Fadahunsi attracted police attention over remarks in a viral recording interpreted as threatening supporters of a rival political party. He disputed that interpretation and offered his explanation of what he meant. That too should be recorded in fairness. But perhaps politicians need reminding of an elementary truth about public communication: intention is only half of meaning. The other half resides in how an audience reasonably receives what has been said. In a society with Nigeria's history of electoral violence, a senior politician cannot casually employ the vocabulary of violence and later be surprised that citizens hear violence.
Then there was Borno. Commissioner Sainna Buba was reported as warning that a finger pointed at his political side could be broken, while those who followed the government would “enjoy the honey” and those who refused would be “flogged”. He subsequently explained that the language was figurative, denied intending violence and apologised. The apology was appropriate and should be acknowledged. But the episode deserves reflection beyond the personality involved. When somebody carrying governmental authority speaks about loyalists enjoying the honey, what exactly is the honey? If it is merely a colourful political expression, it is an unfortunate one. If it refers, even rhetorically, to the benefits of government, then we have wandered into much more dangerous territory, because the resources of government are not the private harvest of the political party temporarily occupying office.
Ebonyi added another phrase to this emerging political dictionary when Governor Francis Nwifuru, responding to allegations of intimidation of opposition figures, reportedly said that they would “see real threat at the right time”. At the same event, he told newly inaugurated local government chairmen that they must not allow the opposition to defeat the APC in their councils in 2027. There is nothing unusual about a governor wanting his party to win every available seat. Politicians are in the business of winning elections, and nobody should pretend otherwise. The difficulty lies in the vocabulary. A governor can say, “Go and convince the people.” He can say, “Show them what we have done.” He can demand political organisation, mobilisation and hard work. But when “threat” enters the conversation, citizens are entitled to wonder whether it is still only a metaphor, particularly because a governor is not an ordinary party canvasser. He presides over considerable instruments of state authority.
Yobe presents perhaps the most unusual case. APC Chairman Muhammad Gadaka reportedly told women whose husbands might prevent them from voting for his party to resist them even to the point of leaving their marriages, adding that he would pay their bride price and marry women divorced for that reason. Again, one can imagine the defence: political humour, rally rhetoric, an exaggerated attempt to excite a crowd. But humour from political leaders deserves scrutiny when the joke is potentially at the expense of social cohesion. The democratic issue here must also be stated carefully. A woman's vote belongs entirely to her. Neither husband nor father nor cleric nor traditional authority is entitled to dictate what she does with her ballot. But the answer to domestic political control cannot be for another politician to turn the marriage itself into a partisan battleground. Democracy should protect the independence of conscience, not require that every human relationship be recruited into party politics. Surely we can defend a woman's political autonomy without asking the family to become another campaign ground.
The danger is not that any one of these statements will necessarily lead directly to violence. The greater danger is familiarity. Democracies have a way of losing vital restraints gradually. What initially shocks us becomes something we joke about. What we joke about becomes something we tolerate. What we tolerate becomes part of political culture, and before long the outrageous becomes ordinary. That is how democratic boundaries move.
At the heart of democracy lies a very simple idea: those who govern do so because citizens consent to be governed by them. The great philosophical traditions of liberal democracy differ on many things, but Locke's consent of the governed, Rousseau's popular sovereignty and Mill's defence of liberty all ultimately return us to the same destination. The citizen must be free to say no. If saying no attracts punishment, exile, deprivation, physical danger or loss of livelihood, then what remains may still carry the outward appearance of democracy, but its moral substance has begun to disappear.
This is why the secret ballot is such a remarkable democratic invention. For a few private moments inside a polling booth, nearly all the inequalities of society are suspended. The billionaire gets one vote. So does the bus conductor. The professor gets one vote. So does the apprentice. The governor gets one vote. So does the woman selling vegetables by the roadside. Money, title, influence and social standing cannot lawfully purchase a second ballot. Democracy reduces us, wonderfully, to political equals. That equality, however, means little if one citizen enters the booth free while another enters carrying fear.
And fear does not require violence to succeed. If a civil servant votes a certain way because she thinks her job may depend upon it, intimidation has already worked. If a trader stays away from a polling unit because he fears what political boys might do afterwards, intimidation has worked. If somebody believes access to a government programme depends upon belonging to the ruling party, coercion has entered the relationship between citizen and state. The fist does not have to land before the threat has achieved its purpose.
Nigeria should understand this better than most countries because our history offers abundant warnings. “Operation Wetie” in the Western Region did not emerge in an intellectual vacuum. It grew from a political environment in which disagreement had become enmity and electoral competition had acquired the character of warfare. The crises of the First Republic, the bitterly disputed politics of the Second Republic and various episodes since the return to civilian rule in 1999 all remind us of the same uncomfortable truth: political violence becomes easier when political opponents are first converted, through language, into enemies.
No party owns this history. That point must be made very clearly. Threatening rhetoric, thuggery, intimidation and abuse of incumbency did not begin with the APC. Nigerian parties have accused one another of precisely these offences for decades. Anybody determined to turn this argument into partisan scorekeeping will find abundant ammunition against almost everybody. But that history cannot become an excuse. If yesterday's government behaved badly, today's government is not thereby licensed to behave badly in exactly the same way. Democracy will never mature if each administration uses the failures of its predecessor as permission for its own.
The governing party carries an additional burden because incumbency changes the meaning of words. When an opposition activist boasts recklessly, one hears a politician talking. When somebody exercising governmental authority makes the same statement, the listener may hear the state somewhere behind the politician. This is the problem. A governor controls enormous administrative machinery. A commissioner participates in government. A council chairman exercises local authority. Citizens may not always know where the politician ends and the office begins. Responsible leaders therefore have a duty to make that boundary unmistakable.
There is also a political economy to all this that we should not ignore. Nigerian elections are often ferocious because the state remains an unusually important distributor of economic opportunity. Political power opens doors to appointments, contracts, projects, licences, patronage, influence and access. For too many political actors, losing office therefore means more than losing an ideological argument; it may mean losing an economic ecosystem. Once politics becomes a struggle over access to rents rather than a competition over ideas, the temptation to buy, bully or frighten the voter becomes much stronger.
That is why the language of “honey” is so revealing. The honey cannot belong to the party. Government belongs to everybody, including those who voted against it. The opposition supporter uses the same road, pays the same taxes, is entitled to the same security and has the same claim upon public institutions as somebody wearing the ruling party's cap. A public hospital is not an APC hospital when the APC governs, any more than it becomes a PDP hospital if power changes hands. The commonwealth cannot become spoils distributed according to party loyalty without the state itself degenerating into an elaborate patronage machine.
There is a cost beyond politics. Investors read countries much as citizens do. They observe economic policy, certainly, but they also observe institutions, political stability, electoral legitimacy and the rule of law. Capital does not like uncertainty. Businesses do not enjoy political disorder. Governments may spend considerable energy telling the world that reforms are improving the investment environment, but the credibility of that message is weakened if election seasons repeatedly produce images of threats, street violence and political intimidation. Political irresponsibility eventually appears on an economic balance sheet, even if the accountant cannot immediately identify the line item.
The international dimension should also matter to Nigeria. We are too consequential a country for our elections to go unnoticed. Nigeria remains central to West African diplomacy, regional security and the democratic fortunes of ECOWAS. Our elections attract international observers, diplomatic missions, development institutions, investors and global news organisations. Nigerians alone must elect Nigerian leaders, but that does not mean the world is not watching the quality of the process. Every viral clip of a public official threatening opponents eventually becomes another small entry in the international ledger from which the health of Nigerian democracy is judged.
This is where the leadership of the APC has a particular responsibility. Its National Chairman, Professor Nentawe Yilwatda, is an academic and public administrator. Its National Secretary, Senator Surajudeen Ajibola Basiru, is a lawyer and former Attorney-General. These are not men who should require elementary instruction about the relationship between institutions, rules and democratic legitimacy. A professor knows that institutions survive through norms as much as written regulations. A lawyer knows that power is legitimate only within boundaries. They therefore have an opportunity to establish a political principle that should be obvious but increasingly needs restating: nobody should threaten a Nigerian in the name of the APC.
That instruction should travel down the party hierarchy without ambiguity. No governor should threaten an opponent. No commissioner should suggest that government benefits belong more to party loyalists. No council chairman should imply that residence in a Nigerian community depends upon electoral choice. No party official should encourage social rupture in pursuit of votes. No campaign operative should imagine that enthusiasm for the ruling party provides immunity from the law. And where these lines are crossed, there should be consequences rather than embarrassed silence followed by another apology when the video goes viral.
This is what governance experts mean by tone from the top. People watch what leaders say, but they watch even more carefully what leaders tolerate. Silence communicates. Selective outrage communicates. Discipline communicates. A party cannot credibly disapprove of political intimidation while allowing repeated examples from within its ranks to pass without institutional response. At some point, failure to condemn becomes part of the message.
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has an even larger role. A President does not need to deliver a lecture on democratic theory. A simple and unequivocal declaration that every Nigerian is entitled to campaign, vote and oppose the government without fear would be enough to establish a line throughout the political structure. Governors would hear it. Commissioners would hear it. Party chairmen would hear it. Local politicians would hear it. Sometimes the most powerful communication from the top is powerful precisely because nobody can plausibly misunderstand it.
The irony is that an incumbent government should have less need for threats than anyone else. It has a record. It has budgets, programmes, projects, policies, reforms, appointments and outcomes upon which it can be judged. The APC can go to Nigerians and say: this is what we inherited, this is what we promised, this is what we have done, this is where we failed, this is what remains unfinished, and this is why we deserve another four years. That is a democratic argument. It may succeed or fail, but it respects the voter. “Vote for us or else” is not an argument at all. It is an admission that persuasion has been abandoned.
There is also a selfish reason for the APC to police this rhetoric aggressively. One reckless statement by an overenthusiastic official can do more reputational damage than months of carefully planned political communication can repair. Governments can spend years explaining reforms and showcasing achievements, only for a thirty-second video of somebody threatening voters to become the material that travels internationally. In the age of the smartphone, the most irresponsible person in a political organisation can momentarily become its most visible spokesperson.
The larger democratic lesson transcends the APC. Nobody governs forever. Every party in power is merely borrowing institutions from the future opposition. The rules one creates today may be used against oneself tomorrow. A party that permits intimidation while it controls government cannot reasonably demand a pristine democratic culture on the day it loses power. Political wisdom therefore requires a simple test before any abuse of incumbency is tolerated: would we be comfortable if our opponents possessed this same power and used it against us?
Nigeria has struggled too long for constitutional government to allow the language of threat to become politically fashionable again. We have enough memories of disputed elections, political thuggery and violence to understand where seemingly casual words can lead. We have enough experience of over-centralised political patronage to understand the danger of confusing party with state. And we surely possess enough democratic maturity to agree on one proposition: nobody should suffer for voting according to conscience.
As 2027 approaches, those asking Nigerians for another mandate should therefore do what democracy requires. They should persuade us with their record, convince us with their ideas, defend their policies, answer their critics and present their programme for the future. Then, when election day arrives, they should allow Nigerians to make their choice without fear, favour or threat. The voter should enter the polling booth with no governor looking over his shoulder, no commissioner hovering over her livelihood, no council chairman questioning whether he belongs, no party official intruding into her family and no political enforcer waiting outside.
That private moment between a citizen and the ballot is where democracy ultimately lives. Protect it, and whatever the result, Nigeria wins. Pollute it with fear, and even victory begins to lose its meaning.
Dr. Mohammed Mohammed Haruna
Political Economist and Public Relations Practitioner
Writes from Minna, Niger State
WHEN POLITICS BEGINS TO SPEAK THE LANGUAGE OF FEAR
Reviewed by Chiroma Archive
on
September 05, 2026
Rating:
No comments: